I'm more looking for certain denominations' official stances on masturbation and less of personal beliefs on the morality of mastubation. I know that there is a biblical passage that some point to that references the "spilling of the seed" and it not being a good thing, but I believe that was Old Testament and I'm wondering if women are held to the same standard, seeing as there is no, ahem, "seed" to be spilled. Well you're thinking of Onan of Genesis fame: "But Onan knew that the offspring would not be his; so whenever he lay with his brother's wife, he spilled his semen on the ground to keep from producing offspring for his brother. In Catholicism, my religion of birth, masturbation was most definately a sin. As with most things with regards to sin since V2, I think it's less emphasized.
Bruce Gerencser Post author July 25, at am. Apart from a person who has taken vow of Vieds, Hindus are free to engage in sexual activites. Apart from the fact that it violates a basic rule of lovemaking which is genital union, masturbation is often in response to a sexual fantasy. Facebook Groups. Find courses and resources which will help you grow to Christian maturity and Baptist views on masturbation apply your faith to your work.
Gerber diaper pins where to buy. Masturbation - Two Views
Is it possible to masturbate without lusting or having unclean thoughts? Answers Relevance. The Bible says that "Everything is legal to me, but not everything is beneficial. Curran; Richard A. It is thought Baptist views on masturbation turning away from sexual sin is turning away from self-indulgence for the purpose of self gratification. Where can we find Scriptures to know if masturbation is right or wrong? It begins with sexual impurity, the defilement of our imagination by depictions of sexual intercourse that present naked bodies as idols for us to admire. Preventing Pregnancy". Masturbation was now valued as an adult, non-pathological, pleasurable activity. See Sharp Press. Contemporary Problems in Moral Theology. Read reviews or order this book safely from Amazon.
From nucleus - autumn - Masturbation - Two Views [pp] The following feature consists of two alternative views on masturbation.
- Chat or rant, adult content, spam, insulting other members, show more.
- Bruce Gerencser March 28, 19 Comments.
- Chat or rant, adult content, spam, insulting other members, show more.
- Sponsored link.
- Among the world's religions, views on masturbation vary widely.
From nucleus - autumn - Masturbation - Two Views [pp] The following feature consists of two alternative views on masturbation. I don't know what you think about the issue, perhaps you have never taken time to consider it carefully.
The following are two opinions, neither represents an official CMF view. They are merely carefully reasoned arguments. Maybe you won't agree with either, perhaps if you are a woman you'll think its irrelevant, or perhaps you'll just reason that the writers have forgotten what it is like to be a young single Christian. All I ask is that you put your prejudices aside and read these two challenging articles with an open mind. The Dionysius Dialogues by Peter Saunders are both interesting and well written with numerous biblical verses to support the views expressed.
I am concerned, however, that their very readability and confident reference to Scripture may make students and others believe that every view represents unquestionable truth. With reference to the July contribution, in particular, I personally agree whole-heartedly with the views expressed that God teaches there is to be no sex except in the context of a lifelong, monogamous relationship between a man and a woman!
I believe, however, that on the issue of masturbation, especially as it affects young, unmarried Christian men, that to call it sin, in the same category and sentence as homosexual acts and premarital sex, is to go 'beyond' Scripture. Hereby an unnecessary and, let us be honest, unmanageable burden is placed on young men. To fail to call something sin that is sin is serious. To label something sin that is not, or even might not be, can be just as dangerous.
May I list some views, quotations and findings about masturbation collected over a 20 year interest in the issue. The Bible does not mention it at all and so there can be no specific biblical prohibition as Peter Saunders himself acknowledged. L Dearborn in an 'Encyclopaedia of Sexual Behaviour' notes, 'No other form of sexual activity has been so frequently discussed, so roundly condemned, and more universally practiced, than masturbation'.
The majority of these men went on to marry and masturbation, for obvious reasons, as well as, for example, physiological ones, became in time less of an issue or often a non-issue. The people who are most affected by this problem, young unmarried 'religious' men, find it in many cases very hard to deal with the subject. When you feel guilty, vulnerable and unsure, it is hard to acknowledge to others you are doing something and so initiate a discussion to ask for help and more satisfactory answers.
The people who could most easily help, married Christian men, especially doctors, who have been through this experience, seem reluctant to relieve the burden on the following generations, despite the fact that they know masturbation caused no harm to them or their marriages, other than the anxiety of guilt feelings at the time.
Let me assure you, I am not trying to give young Christian men a problem if they don't have one. If, however, masturbation is an issue still causing uncertainty and anxiety all around the world and there is evidence to support that view please let us be open about it and see whether, with the combined Godly wisdom of CMF members and others, we can find a more helpful answer.
Vol Foster R. Money, Sex and Power. Hodder and Stoughton, White J. Eros Defiled. IVP, Cummings T et al. Word Publishing, Not God's best? Dr Bates is to be congratulated for his courage in raising this important debate about masturbation which needs far more open discussion in Christian circles than it receives. I can only briefly respond here but my references will give much further detail. The whole crux of the matter, as Dr Bates points out, is whether masturbation is sin or not.
The Bible indeed has nothing directly to say about it but it also has nothing directly to say about voyeurism, fetishim, transsexualism or pornography either. Arguments from silence are never conclusive.
It's also dangerous to quote even well-respected Christian authors as 'gospel'; they may change their mind! In his latest book 'Eros Redeemed', John White unequivocally states that he now believes that 'masturbation is sin. It is not a grave sin, not nearly as serious as pride There are several reasons why I tend to agree with this assessment. Firstly the fact that sexual intercourse is all about relationships and interpersonal communication.
Masturbation is a self-centred activity and if any communication is involved at all it is usually a cry for help. It is true regular pre-marital masturbation doesn't wreck the majority of Christian marriages but does it enhance them either?
Both Bancroft and I have recorded anecdotal cases of marital problems resulting from masturbation, and there is further research literature also documenting this. The universality of masturbation at least for males does not make it right. Pride, economy with the truth and anxiety also seem universal to a greater or lesser degree in the Christians I know.
Furthermore, masturbation is as universal as the shame which follows indulging in it. Bates is mistaken to suggest this shame is a product of evangelical neurosis.
It is a primary shame and occurs in those with a libertarian upbringing as well as those from religious homes. No sexologist with whom I have discussed the subject has denied this universality of shame, nor been able to explain it. Surely God is saying something through the feeling of guilt which masturbation induces?
Finally, Dr Bates makes no mention of pornography the deadly accomplice of masturbation. Pornography is for masturbation, that is its purpose. Most regularly masturbating males will find it all too easy to get involved with porn as it permeates every cinema, shopping centre and home.
The evidence of harm of pornography is in my view overwhelming and masturbation by this means can lead to more serious dangers. I agree that there is far too much guilt and condemnation around among Christians and it is always good for us to check that we are not laying unnecessary burdens on each other. But I remain quite convinced that masturbation is not God's best for his people.
However most of us battle with it at some point in our lives, and we should be more honest in helping each other in the fight. White J. Eros Redeemed. Human Sexuality and its Problems. Churchill Livingstone.
The Family Guide to Sex and Intimacy. Hodder and Stoughton. Male Masturbation. Student Conference Join one of our. Facebook Groups. Draw strength and encouragement by meeting up with like-minded members in your church, community, region, workplace, specialty or via social media.
Find courses and resources which will help you grow to Christian maturity and better apply your faith to your work. Get equipped to speak up confidently and with conviction about what you believe and why in your church, workplace, community and in the public square. Offer your knowledge and experience to serve patients and colleagues both here and abroad through medical work, mentoring, pastoral support, encouragement, prayer, giving or being a CMF Link.
The following feature consists of two alternative views on masturbation. Word Publishing, References White J. Christian Medical Fellowship:. A company limited by guarantee.
Bruce Gerencser, 60, lives in rural Northwest Ohio with his wife of 39 years. Here we have institutions filled with eighteen- to twenty-five-year-old men and women who, with hormones raging, are expected to refrain from physical contact with the opposite sex. This is because it is a form of fornication. With masturbation forbidden and touching the opposite sex grounds for expulsion, what were dating students to do? Otherwise, you sound like a healthy man to me who is concerned that what you do is OK with God. Ten Commandments. The vast majority of dating students — with but a handful of exceptions — broke the rules.
Baptist views on masturbation. Masturbation:
According to Christianity, Christ's death made O. Lust can be twisted into an argument to prohibit masturbation, but all the scriptures about that are related to lusting after a married person. Oh, here's another good passage; Colossians 2: When I was a Southern Baptist, it was.
The biblical justification was the no spilling of seed verses which actually don't refer to masturbation at all, it refers to coitus interuptus - the pull out method - but apparently you can interpret parts of the bible any way you want and as long as the majority of people believe in your interpretation it sticKs.
When I was 12, they separated the girls and boys in a Sunday School class and didn't actually say "masturbation" but that was what they were referring to and the teacher claimed that it made god sad when we 'manipulated' ourselves. Masturbation is a completely normal and natural thing to do and everyone DOES do it. God gave us the gift of masturbation as a part of our sexuality and more people would be leading healthier and happier lives if they didn't feel guilty for engaging in something natural.
Peace, Jenn. Taking the Lord's call in ineffective is whilst human beings use 'God' or 'Jesus' or 'Christ' as expletives and not interior the authentic Christian context. He gave us sexual emotions that have been just to be completely 'given in to' as quickly as we've been married - one guy to a minimum of one woman. If people are going to get into porn to masterbate- one CAN get addicted to porn, and get rotten, distorted ideas of sex from it But it's so totally natural for humans to "explore" themselves.
I get tired of people pushing SO much guilt on people. How many kids have "experimented" yet go on to get married and have totally natural wonderful married sex lives?? Perhaps the remnant fall into some sort of porn or weird sex deviant practice Anyway, you aren't going to hell for being curious and having awakening sexual feelings..
Source s : proud atheist. Joshua Harris is a very good Christian author who writes on the subject of purity. Here is an article from his website. BTW: Is it really possible to do that without lusting? Is it possible to masturbate without lusting or having unclean thoughts? If the answer is no, then Yes it is a sin. What does your bible say?
Ge And Onan knew that the seed should not be his; and it came to pass, when he went in unto his brother's wife, that he spilled it on the ground, lest that he should give seed to his brother. Yup its wrong or shall I say a sin Yes I don't have the passage, but it is considered sodomy i believe right along with anything that can't result in a pregnancy. I wish I could help more. Pagination 1. Existing questions. Is Masturbation considered a sin in the christian religion? More questions.
Individuals who fall prey to this addiction may end up carrying it with them into adult married life, where it can become a serious obstacle to healthy marital intimacy. What can be done to break this pattern? In many cases, masturbation originates as a self-soothing behavior. If you have a problem with masturbation, you may want to keep this in mind and ask yourself whether it might be possible to replace this negative behavior with a more legitimate method of addressing the underlying need.
For example, by talking things over with a friend, reading an engaging book, listening to music, pouring yourself into a constructive project or serving other people. Only a relationship with the Lord can fill that empty space in a deep, lasting and satisfying way. Yet, for all their preaching against the sin of Onanism , virtually all Evangelical teens, young men, and even married men, masturbate.
Being raised in an anti-masturbation church environment caused quite a bit of problem for me as a teen and unmarried adult. While I was a virgin when my wife and I married, I found myself rounding third and heading for home not only with Polly, but also with a girl named Anita. The rest of my dating relationships were casual and of short duration. I was eighteen years old when I started dating Anita. She was twenty, a college student at a Conservative Baptist college in Phoenix, Arizona.
Anita and I, for five short months, had a torrid relationship. She was much more experienced sexually than I was. On more nights than I can remember, we would park along a dark, rarely-travel back road and watch the night sky. Of course, we also did a lot of necking too. Our intimacy stirred my sexual passions to such a degree that I would go home after dates and spend time praying to God for forgiveness, thanking him for not allowing us to give into our sexual desires. For me, not giving in included not masturbating.
I was nineteen, she was seventeen. I planned on playing the field at college, but meeting Polly changed everything. Dating students were expected to keep the rules even during Christmas and summer break. No one, and I mean no one , did so.
Once back at Midwestern, Polly and I were faced with a dilemma. We wanted to continue touching and kissing each other; you know, as dating teens and young adults are wont to do. This meant we would have to secretly break the rules. We sought out couples to double-date with who were not averse to physical contact on dates.
The vast majority of dating students — with but a handful of exceptions — broke the rules. Some students even slid into home and had sexual intercourse. The Midwestern dorm was a den of raging hormones. With masturbation forbidden and touching the opposite sex grounds for expulsion, what were dating students to do? IFB young adults were very much like their counterparts in the world — the ss world.
We, like our peers, wanted sexual intimacy without fear and guilt. Masturbation, then, was common among male students in the Midwestern dorm. More than one IFB luminary suggested quick, cold showers to ward off masturbatory temptations. Each dorm room had a periodic responsibility to clean the dorm bathrooms, including the showers. Yuck, I know, but have you ever been in a male dormitory shower room? IFB preachers and their Evangelical counterparts continue to preach against the sin of masturbation.
Despite all their preaching, masturbation remains widely practiced. Masturbation is a harmless, effective way to find sexual release. Wanting to obey God and their preachers , Evangelical unmarrieds do their best to refrain from sexual intercourse before marriage.
What really should happen, of course, is for Evangelical churches and colleges to begin endorsing safe, responsible sexual intimacy among unmarrieds. With the average age for young people marrying in their late 20s, it is absurd to expect them to refrain from sex for ten to fifteen years before they tie the knot.
Much like non-believing young adults, Evangelical unmarrieds, more often than not, have had sex before marriage. Maybe then, young adults might be less likely to flee the confines of Evangelical Christianity. Perhaps, it is time to rewrite or update the Good Book, striking from its pages all the sexually repressive rules and regulations. Imagine how much more attentive young adults might be on Sundays if they were able to have guilt-free sex the night before. And you too, Preacher Man. Were you raised in the IFB or Evangelical church?
Please leave your thoughts in the comment section. Bruce Gerencser, 60, lives in rural Northwest Ohio with his wife of 39 years. He and his wife have six grown children and eleven grandchildren. Bruce pastored Evangelical churches for twenty-five years in Ohio, Texas, and Michigan. Bruce left the ministry in , and in he left Christianity. Bruce is now a humanist and an atheist. For more information about Bruce, please read the About page.
Bruce is a local photography business owner, operating Defiance County Photo out of his home. If you live in Northwest Ohio and would like to hire Bruce, please email him. Thank you for reading this post. Please share your thoughts in the comment section. If you are a first-time commenter, please read the commenting policy before wowing readers with your words. All first-time comments are moderated. If you would like to contact Bruce directly, please use the contact form to do so.
Donations are always appreciated. Donations on a monthly basis can be made through Patreon. One-time donations can be made through PayPal. Subscribe to the Daily Post Digest! Sign up now and receive an email every day containing the new posts for that day. I will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time. There is only one way the church can help an adolescent and that is through a dedicated ministry that offers them free spectacles.
And the church should do it before the whole population of young people go blind! Let him with an empty hand, cast the first stone. Repression repression repression was the name of the game. I had A LOT of sexual hangup that took me years to recover from due to all this teaching.
Sexual drives are normal and there is nothing wrong with expressing them in a safe, responsible, consensual manner. These hyper religious people are control freaks. It is sick. As for the assumption that sex within marriage is, by definition, honourable, virtuous etc, I just shake my head.
Speak to the millions of women all over the world who are raped within marriage as a matter of course. And speak to their children who are harmed by growing up in such environments. Far too many Christians obsess more about consensual behaviour than they do about that.
My big question is why? In fact most evangelical churches today are closer to the teachings of the Pharisees instead of Jesus.
I have a gay daughter and she is one of the most amazing people you could ever meet. I refuse to condemn and vilify her over her sexual orientation. It just greatly disappoints me. Agree wholeheartedly. Shakabah is in verse To understand it better, shakab is used in verse 18 that mean a man is actively having sexual intercourse with his wife and he ejaculates in her vagina. In verse 16, shakabah, is used without the woman present.
Notice that verse 17 explains it like we all men understand: since we spurt all over the place when we masturbate, it makes sense God instructs the man to clean up not only his body, but everthing that his semen splattered on. In verse 18, God tells both the man and his wife how to clean their bodies, not everything within 4 or 5 feet of his penis. Shakabah has the -ah suffix on shakab. See Genesis where God tells men that He has His provision for him, his future wife. They were fishermen, despised tax collectors, etc.
Masturbation - Two Views
Sexual intimacy within marriage is a beautiful gift from God. As a father, I long for my children to enjoy the bond of marriage without the baggage of past sexual sin, yet I know full well how rarely people maintain purity.
Many medical professionals treat masturbation as a natural part of human development, and some church leaders have attempted to supply practical and theological reasons to masturbate. However, I do not believe this approach pleases God, and I have seen the devastation that such a practice brings to both singles and marrieds alike. My focus here is to clarify biblically why engaging in such activity outside the marriage bed is sinful and should therefore be avoided.
Elsewhere I have expanded on my arguments. We cannot stand against sexual temptation in our own strength. In Christ, we become a new creation. From this perspective, I offer the following thoughts about the practice of masturbation in the life of one who is in Christ:.
God purposed that all righteous forms of sexual expression be for the marriage bed. Sexual expression manifest in orgasm is a good gift of God 1 Timothy —5 that men and women are to enjoy only in the context of marital intimacy Genesis ; Song —6; 1 Corinthians —5; Hebrews When people reach orgasm outside the covenant-confirming act of lovemaking in marriage, the act expresses a lack of self-control and becomes solely self-seeking, divorced from its purpose of creating intimacy.
Sexual intimacy between a husband and wife points to the love between Christ and his church. Masturbation outside the marriage bed does not glorify God because evil desire always fuels it. Any desire is evil that we exert at a wrong time or for a wrong object, and God focuses the proper time and object of sexual desire in marriage. As such, evil desire fuels all sexual expression outside the marriage bed, including masturbation, so we must treat all such acts as sinful and as deserving of hell Matthew —30; Mark —23; 1 Corinthians —10; Galatians , 19—21; Ephesians ; Colossians —6.
As men and women of God, therefore, may we not engage in it. Instead, may we look to our Lord for help and seek to honor him with our bodies by allowing our only outlet for sexual desire to be the covenant-nurturing intimacy of marital lovemaking Job The one who calls us to holiness is faithful, and he will surely bring it about 1 Thessalonians — Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. About Apply. Is Masturbation Okay? Glorify God in Your Body Many medical professionals treat masturbation as a natural part of human development, and some church leaders have attempted to supply practical and theological reasons to masturbate.
Controlling Our Bodies in Holiness and Honor From this perspective, I offer the following thoughts about the practice of masturbation in the life of one who is in Christ: 1.
View Unreached People of the Day. Audio and Video Sites Soundcloud Vimeo.